Sena Qiao Group

Insights · Quality control

What AQL 2.5 means for furniture and lighting buyers

AQL 2.5 does not mean your order is 2.5% defective. It means the inspector accepts more defects than most buyers expect. On a 1,000-piece lighting order inspected at AQL 2.5, a lot where 1 in 20 units has a major defect still passes about 79% of the time.

If you buy furniture or lighting from Asia, AQL 2.5 is probably already in your inspection booking. This post explains what that number does, what it does not do, and how to set it so it protects your margin.

The short answer

Acceptable Quality Limit (AQL) is a sampling rule from ISO 2859-1 and its US equivalent, ANSI/ASQ Z1.4. The inspector does not check every unit. The inspector pulls a random sample, counts defects, and compares the count to a pass/fail number in the table.

AQL 2.5 is the level most inspection firms use for major defects: problems that affect function or appearance enough that a customer returns the product or leaves a bad review. Typical examples are a misaligned cabinet door or a chip on a visible edge.

Most furniture and interior-product inspections use this plan (Dream View China; ClearToLoad):

  • Critical defects: 0 allowed. Anything unsafe or illegal to sell.
  • Major defects: AQL 2.5.
  • Minor defects: AQL 4.0.

How the inspector gets the numbers

The inspector uses 2 tables:

  1. Your lot size and the inspection level give a code letter. General Inspection Level II is the default unless you specify another one.
  2. The code letter and the AQL give a sample size, an accept number (Ac), and a reject number (Re).

If the sample has defects at or under Ac, the lot passes. If it has defects at or over Re, the lot fails.

Here are the numbers at General Inspection Level II for common furniture and lighting order sizes (ANSI/ASQ Z1.4 summary, Tetra Inspection; ClearToLoad AQL chart):

Lot size (units) Code Sample size Major, AQL 2.5 (Ac / Re) Minor, AQL 4.0 (Ac / Re)
151 to 280 G 32 2 / 3 3 / 4
281 to 500 H 50 3 / 4 5 / 6
501 to 1,200 J 80 5 / 6 7 / 8
1,201 to 3,200 K 125 7 / 8 10 / 11
3,201 to 10,000 L 200 10 / 11 14 / 15

Example: you order 400 dining chairs. The inspector checks 50 chairs. If 3 chairs have major defects, the lot passes. If 4 have major defects, the lot fails.

Not every website prints these numbers correctly. Some AQL pages online list the wrong accept numbers for a given lot size. Before you approve a report, check the numbers against the official table.

Why "2.5" is not a 2.5% defect rate

Look at the 1,000-unit row. The inspector samples 80 units and accepts up to 5 major defects. That is a 6.25% defect rate in the sample, and the lot still passes.

The math works the other way too. We calculated the chance that a lot passes at AQL 2.5, Level II, using a standard binomial model:

True major-defect rate in the lot 1,000 units (sample 80, Ac 5) 2,000 units (sample 125, Ac 7) 5,000 units (sample 200, Ac 10)
2.5% 98% pass 99% pass 99% pass
4% 90% pass 87% pass 82% pass
5% 79% pass 71% pass 58% pass
8% 38% pass 21% pass 7% pass

AQL protects you from bad lots. It does not protect you from mediocre lots. A factory that runs at 4% to 5% major defects passes most AQL 2.5 inspections. On a 1,000-unit order, a lot with 5% major defects still passes about 4 times in 5.

Before SQG, I spent 4 years, from 2007 to 2011, managing contract manufacturing projects across China, Vietnam, and the US, and 6 years in furniture manufacturing. I have stood on a factory floor at final inspection the day before a container was supposed to load, and the product was not right. At that point the AQL table cannot help you. The lot fails and your ship date slips, or it passes on a sample and the problem lands in your warehouse. That time, the cause was the glass. The panels did not fit, and nobody had put glass fit on the defect list, so no one checked it before final inspection. If your product has glass in a frame, list glass fit as a major defect and give the tolerance in millimeters.

Where furniture and lighting buyers lose money

You never defined "major." If your inspection checklist does not say what counts as major, the inspector decides on site. A 2 mm gap on a drawer front may be minor to the inspector and major to your customer. Write the defect list before production starts, with photos and tolerances in millimeters.

Lighting safety items get classed as major. For lighting, these defects are critical, with zero allowed:

  • an exposed live part
  • a failed dielectric (hi-pot) test
  • a failed ground-continuity test
  • a missing or wrong certification mark on a listed product

If your checklist leaves these at AQL 2.5, the inspector can pass a lot with unsafe units in the sample.

You count units, but the inspector counts defects. One lamp with a scratched shade and a loose base can count as 1 defective unit or 2 defects. Agree on the counting rule with the inspection firm in writing.

You use Level II for everything. Level II is a default, not a recommendation. For a first order with a new factory, or the lot after a failed inspection, use General Inspection Level III, which pulls a bigger sample (Importivity). For destructive tests such as a carton drop test, the inspector uses a special level with a much smaller sample, because each tested unit is a unit you cannot sell.

You inspect only at the end. A pre-shipment inspection finds problems after production is finished. At that point you can only rework the lot or negotiate a discount, and both delay your shipment. For furniture with custom finishes, or lighting with a new driver or a new LED supplier, add a during-production inspection at about 20% to 30% completion.

What to set in your next inspection booking

If you buy furniture or lighting, start from this plan and adjust by product:

  1. Critical: 0. For lighting, list every electrical safety item by name.
  2. Major: AQL 2.5. If you sell premium products or your return rate is above your margin target, tighten to AQL 1.5.
  3. Minor: AQL 4.0.
  4. Inspection level: General II for repeat orders with clean history. General III for a first order or the lot after a failure.
  5. Defect list: written, with photos and tolerances, signed by the factory before production.
  6. Counting rule: defects or defective units, agreed in writing.

If your next furniture or lighting order ships in the next 90 days, send us the product spec and your current inspection plan. We will tell you if it is a project we can manage, and which defect classes we would set differently.

Sources

← All insights